This Is Killing Your Email Marketing (And What To Do Instead)

In partnership with

You work hard on your emails.

You polish your subject lines. You tweak your CTAs. You obsess over your design.

But when you check the numbers… it’s crickets.

Low opens. Fewer clicks. Fewer conversions.

And you’re left wondering: “Is it my list? Is it my offer? Am I just bad at this?”

Spoiler: It’s none of that.

The truth is simpler, and deadlier:

Your emails sound like every other email in their inbox.

Let’s get honest:

• "Hi [Name], hope you’re well..."

• "Just checking in..."

• "I wanted to reach out because..."

If your opening line feels like it was written by a polite robot, your email’s already dead on arrival.

That first line? It’s make or break. And most brands are breaking it.

Sponsored

A free newsletter with the marketing ideas you need

The best marketing ideas come from marketers who live it.

That’s what this newsletter delivers.

The Marketing Millennials is a look inside what’s working right now for other marketers. No theory. No fluff. Just real insights and ideas you can actually use—from marketers who’ve been there, done that, and are sharing the playbook.

Every newsletter is written by Daniel Murray, a marketer obsessed with what goes into great marketing. Expect fresh takes, hot topics, and the kind of stuff you’ll want to steal for your next campaign.

Because marketing shouldn’t feel like guesswork. And you shouldn’t have to dig for the good stuff.

Sign Up Free

The Inescapable Truth: Email Is an Attention Game

Most businesses treat email like a rational medium. They believe that if the message is clear, the benefits are strong, and the product makes sense, then it’ll convert.

But email doesn’t live in the rational brain. It lives in the primitive brain, the part that reacts before it thinks.

Which is why predictability is lethal.

Once your reader’s brain recognizes a pattern it’s seen before, it tunes out. It says, "I know what this is", and moves on. The email is mentally deleted before the click ever happens.

So what actually gets read? Messages that break the pattern. That interrupt the scroll. That feel different.

So How Do You Disrupt the Pattern?

Here are 5 messaging tactics that break expectations and earn attention:

1. Drop the Reader Into the Action

Skip the pleasantries. Start with a punch.

These lines don’t introduce the story. They are the story.

This works because the human brain is hardwired to respond to threats and surprises. It’s a survival instinct. When your opener feels like a plot twist or a crisis, it activates the brain’s “what’s going on here?” mechanism. You get attention before the rational mind has time to say “nah.”

2. Use Contradictions That Confuse (In a Good Way)

Cognitive dissonance = attention magnet.

These openers create tension in the brain. They don’t make immediate sense, and that’s exactly why the reader has to keep reading. The brain wants closure. It needs an explanation.

If your email doesn’t create a question, it won’t get an answer. And that answer is your pitch.

3. Confess Something Uncomfortable

Trust skyrockets when you admit a "flaw" that doesn’t actually hurt your offer.

It feels real. It feels honest. And in a sea of slick pitches and overhyped promises, honesty wins.

The best part? These confessions often make your offer more desirable. They say, "We’re not here to impress, we’re here to deliver." That’s credibility money can’t buy.

4. Get Agreement Before You Sell

Start with what your reader already knows or feels:

Every “yes” you stack in their mind lowers resistance to your pitch. It creates an unconscious rhythm of agreement. And when people agree with you, they’re more likely to keep agreeing, even when you shift to your offer.

This is persuasion without pressure. Alignment before action.

5. Frame Your Message as Shared Knowledge

Use phrasing that feels like accepted truth:

These statements slide past resistance. They don’t feel like you're selling something new, they feel like you're reminding them of something they already believe.

Instead of saying “we think this might help,” try saying “you probably already know this is a problem…”

It reframes your email from being a pitch to being a reminder. And people are far more open to reminders than they are to new information, especially in the inbox.

The New Rule: Every Line Must Earn the Next

Forget structure. Forget templates. Your only job is to keep the reader wanting one more line.

Your opener buys you the next sentence. That sentence buys you the next one. If the chain breaks, the click dies.

If your opener doesn’t interrupt the scroll, it doesn’t matter how good the rest is. No one will see it.

This is why great email copy often looks strange. It feels unpolished, or raw, or like a conversation caught mid-thought. That’s intentional. That’s what makes it work.

TL;DR: 5 Ways to Break the Pattern and Own the Inbox

1. Lead with tension – Drop them into a moment of action or chaos.

2. Say something that doesn’t make sense (yet) – Contradictions beg to be resolved.

3. Admit a flaw – Trust is built when you drop the polish.

4. Start with a string of yeses – Stack agreement before the pitch.

5. Talk like it’s already understood – Truth phrased as reminder gets less resistance.

Challenge: Rewrite Your First Two Lines

Grab one of your existing emails.
Delete the intro.
Replace it with something that:

• Starts with tension

• Surprises them

• Confesses something real

• Breaks their expectation

Don’t worry about perfection. Worry about pulling them in.

Then watch what happens to your open rate. Watch how clicks rise. Watch how readers start responding instead of ignoring.

Cheers
The InBoXer Team