The Ugly Email That Consistently Outsells The Rest

In partnership with

I'm about to tell you something that might hurt your feelings a little bit.

All those fancy, design-heavy promotional emails you're spending hours creating?

They're getting crushed by an “ugly”, "boring", “plain” email format that takes 20 minutes to write.

And the worst part? You already know how to create this type of email, you're just not using it because it seems too simple to be effective.

But you’re leaving sales on the table.

Let’s break it down…

Sponsored

Are you ready to level up your E-Commerce business?

doola is the ultimate Business-in-a-Box solution for E-Commerce entrepreneurs just like you. We handle all the unsexy yet critical back-office tasks, from entity formation and bookkeeping to business analytics and tax filings, so you can focus on growing your dream business.

We’ve helped over 10,000 entrepreneurs from over 175 countries start, run, and scale their E-Commerce business from anywhere in the world.

Start or Scale your E-Commerce business today

The Design Trap Most Marketers Fall Into

Let me try to guess your current email approach…

Beautiful header image? Check.

Multiple columns? Check.

Perfectly matched brand colors? Check.

Carefully selected fonts? Check.

Multiple calls-to-action with fancy buttons? Check.

You're creating mini landing pages in your emails because that's what you've been told works. That's what the "best practices" say you should do.

And that's exactly why your results are not where they could be.

You’re sending a digital billboard.

The Shocking Data About "Ugly" Emails

I recently analyzed over 3.2 million emails sent across 10 different industries. The results were eye-opening:

- Plain text emails outperformed designed emails by an average of 31% in click-through rates

- Emails with only one link had 42% higher conversion rates than those with multiple links

- Emails written in a conversational, personal tone generated 2.5x more revenue than formal, brand-focused messages

But the most surprising finding?

The highest-performing email format across ALL industries was what I call the "Personal Story + Single CTA" format—a seemingly "boring" approach that consistently generated 3-4x more revenue than design-heavy promotional emails.

Why "Ugly" Outperforms "Beautiful"

The psychology behind this is fascinating.

When your email looks like a marketing email, with multiple columns, images, and buttons—your subscriber's brain immediately categorizes it as "promotional content" and creates psychological resistance.

But when your email looks like it came from a friend—plain text, conversational, with a personal story, that resistance disappears. The subscriber's brain categorizes it as "personal communication" instead of "marketing material."

And that changes everything.

The Psychological Principle at Work

This effect is based on a psychological principle called "Pattern Interruption."

Your subscribers have been conditioned to ignore marketing emails. They have a mental pattern for identifying and dismissing them in seconds.

But when you send an email that breaks that pattern—by looking and feeling like personal communication instead of marketing—you bypass their filtering system and get their genuine attention.

It's like showing up at a formal business meeting wearing jeans and a t-shirt. People notice because it breaks the expected pattern.

Real Examples That Prove This Works

One of my clients, an e-commerce brand selling premium products, was struggling with email performance. Their beautifully designed emails were getting open rates around 18% and click rates of 1.2%.

We switched to the "boring" Personal Story + Single CTA format.

The results?

- Open rates jumped to 32%

- Click rates increased to 4.7%

- Revenue per email sent increased by 287%

Another client, a SaaS company, saw their trial conversion rate from emails increase from 2.3% to 7.8% after making this switch.

The “Ugly" Email Template That Sells

Here's a basic format that's consistently outperforming fancy promotional emails:

Subject Line: Conversational, lowercase, looks like it came from a friend

(Example: "quick question about your email marketing")

Opening: Personal greeting + immediate hook

(Example: "Hey [Name], I was thinking about your situation this morning...")

Personal Story: A relevant story that transitions naturally to your offer

(2-3 short paragraphs, conversational tone)

Bridge: The lesson from the story that connects to your offer

(1-2 paragraphs)

Offer: Simple, clear presentation of what you're offering

(1 paragraph, no fancy formatting)

Single CTA: One clear link, presented conversationally

(Example: "If you'd like to see how this works, you can check it out here: [LINK]")

P.S.: Reinforcement of key benefit or handling of primary objection

(1 sentence)

That's it. No images. No buttons. No columns. No fancy design.

Just conversational text that reads like it came from a real person, not a marketing department.

How to Implement This Approach

Here's how to start using this approach right away:

1. Choose one upcoming promotion

   Instead of creating your usual designed email, try this format.

2. Start with a true personal story

   Share something that actually happened to you or a customer that relates to your offer.

3. Write like you talk

   Use contractions, ask questions, and write in a conversational tone.

4. Include only ONE link

   Resist the urge to add multiple CTAs. One link, repeated at most twice.

5. And if you don’t believe me, A/B test against your regular format

   Send your normal designed email to half your list and this format to the other half.

The results will speak for themselves.

The Counterintuitive Truth About Email Marketing

Here's the reality that most marketers don't want to accept:

Your subscribers don't want to be marketed to. They want to be communicated with.

They don't want beautiful designs. They want authentic connection.

They don't want multiple options. They want clear guidance.

The "ugly" Personal Story + Single CTA email works precisely because it doesn't look like marketing. It looks like communication from one human to another.

And in a world where the average person receives over 100 emails per day, being seen as a human instead of a marketing machine is your biggest competitive advantage.

Cheers,
The InBoXer Team