- InBoXer
- Posts
- Freeze Your Cold Leads
Freeze Your Cold Leads
In partnership with
Most marketers treat cold leads like a dying fire.
They gently nurture them, hoping a little warmth will bring them back.
But the truth? Most cold leads stay cold.
And slow-dripping them “value” emails is like trying to microwave ice.
You’ll just end up with a lukewarm mess.
The real way to re-engage a cold lead? “Freeze them”.
Let me explain…
[Keep reading👇]
Advertisement
Run ads IRL with AdQuick
With AdQuick, you can now easily plan, deploy and measure campaigns just as easily as digital ads, making them a no-brainer to add to your team’s toolbox.
You can learn more at www.AdQuick.com
Stop Warming Up Cold Leads—Freeze Them Into Action
Marketers love the idea of “warming up” cold leads.
The logic sounds good on the surface:
Drip them a few helpful emails…
Slowly rekindle interest…
And hope they eventually buy.
But let’s be honest…How often does that actually work?
More often than not, these cold leads stay cold. They ignore your “value emails,” delete your “helpful tips,” and move on with their lives.
Why?
Because people don’t take action when they’re comfortable.
And a slow, nurturing sequence keeps them exactly where they are—on the sidelines.
So instead of warming them up… it’s time to freeze them into an immediate decision.
“Are They In Or Out?”
The ‘Shock and Decide’ Method
Instead of trying to gently reintroduce cold leads to your brand, you need to hit them with a high-stakes, impactful message that forces an immediate decision.
Here’s what this looks like in practice:
Step 1: Call Out Their Silence
Subject Line: “We need to talk…”
🔥 Email Opener:
“I’ve noticed you haven’t engaged with my emails in a while. Maybe you’ve been busy. Maybe my messages haven’t been hitting the mark. Or maybe… you’re just not interested anymore.”
By acknowledging their silence upfront, you reframe the relationship. You’re not here to beg.
They need to make a choice.
Step 2: Paint the Picture of Inaction
Most people don’t realize that doing nothing is also a decision.
“Right now, you’re in the worst possible position—doing nothing. You had an interest in [solution], but hesitation kills results.”
By making their inaction feel uncomfortable, you trigger the need for change.
Step 3: Give Them a Hard Choice
“So, here’s the deal. You have two choices today:
✅ If you’re serious about [goal], click here and let’s get moving.
❌ If not, just ignore this email, and I’ll remove you from my list.”
No pressure. No guilt. Just a simple YES or NO decision.
This flips the script. Instead of you trying to convince them, it forces them to decide whether they still belong on your list.
End with a simple but direct challenge:
“No hard feelings either way. But I can promise you this—waiting and doing nothing gets you nowhere. So, what’s it going to be?”
At this point, they either:
Click and re-engage (win!)
Ignore it and get removed from your list (also a win—no more dead weight).
Why This Works
✅ Creates an Emotional Response – People are wired to respond to urgency, not slow nudges.
✅ Triggers Loss Aversion – The fear of “being removed” can spark action.
✅ Filters Out the Dead Leads – You only keep engaged, relevant contacts.
✅ Establishes You as the Authority – You’re not chasing; you’re leading.
And best of all? It works fast. No need for a drawn-out, 12-email nurture sequence. Just one email that forces action now.
How to Implement This Today
🔹 Find a segment of cold leads (haven’t engaged in 60-90 days).
🔹 Craft a “Shock and Decide” email using this framework.
🔹 Send it and watch the responses roll in.
Some people will re-engage. Others won’t. Either way, you’re no longer stuck in “nurture mode,” waiting for leads who may never come back.
This approach is not for the timid.
But if you’re tired of spinning your wheels with “gentle” nurture sequences that don’t convert, it’s time to take a stand.
Because the best way to get cold leads to act… is to force them to decide.
Now, go test it.
Cheers
The InBoXer Team
What did you think of todays edition? |