Fix This Before You Write Another Word of Copy

In partnership with

More sales die because of a weak offer than a weak headline.

But you wouldn’t know that by the way most marketers behave.

They’ll obsess over their copy. Rewrite the hero section 12 times. Tweak the button text from “Get Started” to “Yes, I Want This” and back again.

Meanwhile, the real killer, the offer, sits untouched. Misaligned, unclear, and unappealing.

It’s like polishing a billboard for a product no one wants. You can make it witty. You can make it beautiful. But it’s still pointing to a dead end.

The hard truth? Great copy can only amplify desire. It can’t manufacture it.

If your offer doesn’t hit a real need, solve a real problem, or make your audience feel something… the copy isn’t broken. The strategy is.

And until you fix that? Every subject line, every CTA, every ad, you’re just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic.

Let’s talk about how to change that.

Sponsored

Try Artisan’s All-in-one Outbound Sales Platform & AI BDR

Ava automates your entire outbound demand generation so you can get leads delivered to your inbox on autopilot. She operates within the Artisan platform, which consolidates every tool you need for outbound:

• 300M+ High-Quality B2B Prospects, including E-Commerce and Local Business Leads

• Automated Lead Enrichment With 10+ Data Sources

• Full Email Deliverability Management

• Multi-Channel Outreach Across Email & LinkedIn

• Human-Level Personalization

Book a demo to see what Ava can do.

“We hired a $15K copywriter… and it still flopped.”

That line stopped me in my tracks.

The product looked polished. The funnel was beautiful. The copy? Sharp. It had curiosity, it had benefits, it hit all the persuasion triggers. Everything should’ve worked. But it didn’t.

Why?

Because the offer itself was weak.

And that’s what most marketers refuse to admit.

We’ve been taught to obsess over copy, to chase the perfect hook, headline, CTA, and angle, as if words alone can make someone want something they never cared about in the first place.

They can’t.

Don’t get me wrong, great copywriting matters.

A lot.

It can elevate a strong offer to new levels. It can accelerate trust, clarify value, and spark action.

But copy is not a magic trick. It’s a magnifier. If what it’s magnifying is broken, confusing, or unwanted… you’re just yelling louder into the void.

This is one of the biggest misconceptions in marketing today.

People throw money at high-end copywriters or AI prompts or endless rewrites thinking that this version will be the breakthrough.

But the real bottleneck isn’t phrasing, it’s positioning.

Most of the time, the offer is simply not desirable enough.

It doesn’t solve an urgent problem.

It’s not different enough to stand out. It’s priced in a way that doesn’t align with perceived value. Or, this one hurts, it’s just not something people want.

And I get it. You’ve poured time, money, energy into creating this thing.

You’re emotionally invested. You want the copy to be the issue because that means you can fix it quickly.

But the market doesn’t care how hard you worked. It only cares whether your offer is immediately relevant, clearly valuable, and distinctly better than other options out there.

A great offer doesn’t need copy to be brilliant, it just needs copy to explain it well. But a bad offer? Even the most hypnotic prose won’t turn it into a winner.

So what actually makes an offer weak?

Here’s a quick gut check:

• Does your value proposition take more than one sentence to explain? That’s a red flag. If someone can’t “get it” instantly, they won’t keep listening.

• Are you solving a “nice to have” problem, not a “must fix” urgent pain point? Pain always out-converts potential.

• Is your price aligned with perceived value, or does it cause friction? Too high without justification or too low without trust both kill momentum.

• Can someone look at your offer and say, “I’ve seen this before”? If you’re not different, you’re invisible.

Here’s the truth: If your offer isn’t converting, don’t touch the copy until you’ve revisited the offer itself.

Ask tougher questions. Talk to your audience again.

Dig deeper into what they actually want, not what you think they want.

And once you’ve rebuilt your offer into something undeniably valuable, the copy becomes fun again. You’re no longer trying to invent desire, you’re channeling it.

Want to stress-test your offer? Do this:

1. Strip it down. Describe it in one sentence to a stranger. Do they “get it” immediately? Are they intrigued?

2. Pre-sell it. Can you get someone to buy or commit before you’ve finished building it? That’s the ultimate validation.

3. Compare it directly. Look at your top 3 competitors. What makes your offer the obvious choice over theirs?

Most marketers never do this work. They keep fiddling with the surface while ignoring the foundation. But the real pros? They obsess over the offer first, and then unleash powerful copy to accelerate the win.

So next time you’re tempted to rewrite your VSL script or tweak your headline for the sixth time… pause. Ask:

Because once the offer is right, everything else flows. The copy becomes easier. Ads perform better. Emails convert more. It all stacks.

Remember: words don’t sell. Value sells. Copy just helps people see that value faster.

So fix the offer first.

Polish the copy second.

And watch what happens when your message finally aligns with something your audience actually wants.

Cheers
The InBoXer Team