Curiosity That Converts: The Art of Earning Opens (Without Clickbait)

In partnership with

Picture this: You get an email with the subject line, “This one weird trick made me $100K in 30 days!” Your curiosity is piqued, kind of. You click. The email starts with a vague story, ends with a pitch, and offers no real insight. You feel a bit… cheated.

Clickbait just happened to you.

Now contrast that with an email titled, “The pricing tweak that doubled our conversions.” You open it, read a specific strategy you can try yourself, and finish feeling smarter. That’s earned curiosity, and it's the secret sauce of high-performing email marketing.

If you’re serious about building trust, engagement, and revenue from your email list, this isn’t just a “nice-to-have.” It’s the strategy.

Let’s break it down.

Sponsored

2x conversions by pre-testing your ads? Yes, it's possible!

Instead of crossing your fingers the next time you run ads, what if you would know your ad performance before you even go live?

With Neurons AI, you can.

It gives you quick, actionable recommendations to improve your creatives and maximize your ad impact. Run A/B tests before launch and tweak your visuals for maximum brand impact.

Global brands like Google, Facebook, and Coca-Cola are already using Neurons to boost their campaigns.

We're talking 73% increases in CTR and 20% jumps in brand awareness.

Get Your Neurons Demo

The Clickbait Trap: Easy Open, Zero Trust

Clickbait plays on our natural curiosity, like a magician asking, “Wanna see a trick?”, but it doesn’t follow through.

Clickbait:

• Overpromises (“You won’t believe what happened next!”)

• Under-delivers (you will believe it… and you’ll be annoyed you clicked)

• Kills trust (once readers feel tricked, you’ve lost them)

It’s like the marketing equivalent of catfishing. Sure, you might get a date (or a click), but there won’t be a second one.

What Real Curiosity Looks Like

Genuine curiosity doesn’t shout, “Click me now!” It whispers something you feel compelled to know more about. It introduces a knowledge gap, the psychological discomfort of knowing just enough to want the rest of the story.

That’s what a great subject line should do.

Examples:

• “We stopped selling in our emails. Sales doubled.”

• “Why our worst-performing ad is still running”

• “The surprising reason your welcome sequence fails by email 3”

Each of these plants a question in the reader’s mind: Why? How? What happened? That’s curiosity, without the slime.

The Secret Ingredient: Payoff

Curiosity gets the open. Payoff earns the trust.

This is where most marketers mess up. They tease well… but teach poorly. You need to close the loop on the promise you made in the subject line.

If your subject is “How we 3x’d open rates with a single word,” your email had better include:

• The word you used

• Why it worked

• How the reader can apply it

Bonus points if you include screenshots, stats, or templates. This is how you go from being just another email to being a must-read in their inbox.

Build a Curiosity-Driven Email (That Actually Works)

Let’s walk through a basic structure:

1. Subject Line: Create the Curiosity Gap

   • Tease a result, conflict, or shift in thinking.

   • Don’t reveal the whole story, just enough to make them want it.

2. Opening Line: Expand the Hook

   • Reiterate the curiosity without being repetitive.

   • Hint at why it matters to them.

3. Body: Deliver the Payoff

   • Share the insight or lesson.

   • Include specifics, numbers, quotes, strategies, examples.

   • No fluff. You’re buying trust here.

4. CTA: Show the Next Step

   • Invite them to learn more, try something, or reply back.

   • If you’re selling, make the offer feel like a logical next move, not a bait-and-switch.

Case Study: From “Meh” to Must-Read

Let’s say you run a SaaS company that helps e-commerce brands optimize checkout pages. Here’s the clickbait version of your email:

• Subject Line: “How we made $50,000 in a weekend (with zero ad spend)”

• Email Body: Teases a vague launch, links to a sales page. Little detail, mostly hype.

Now try this:

• Subject Line: “The one checkout tweak that lifted our cart completions by 28%”

• Email Body:

Now that is curiosity with payoff.

Why This Strategy Wins Long-Term

• You build reputation: Your emails get opened because people trust they’ll learn something.

• You reduce unsubscribes: No one unsubscribes from emails that make them smarter or better.

• You prime for conversion: Value-first emails warm up leads so when you do pitch, they’re ready.

Think about your own inbox. Which senders do you always open? Probably the ones who teach, not tease.

The Wrap-Up

Forget “you won’t believe what happened next.” You’re not BuzzFeed. You’re a trusted guide, a teacher, a value-deliverer.

Curiosity isn’t about hiding answers, it’s about revealing just enough to make someone want to learn. Payoff isn’t just about delivering value, it’s about making sure your readers feel smarter, not sold.

Want clicks? Tease.
Want customers? Teach.

Cheers
The InBoXer Team