Big Beautiful Emails

In partnership with

Every marketer knows the feeling: You spend hours polishing a beautiful, branded email. The layout is tight. The colors are on-point. It looks fantastic.

Then you send it out…
…and the numbers barely budge.

Meanwhile, someone on your team fires off a quick, casual follow-up in plain text, and it outperforms your masterpiece.

Why? Because in the world of email marketing, beautiful doesn’t always mean effective.

It turns out the emails that look the least like marketing are often the ones that perform like it.

Let’s dig in…

Sponsored

Influencer code protection made simple

KeepCart: Coupon Protection partners with D2C brands like Quince, Blueland, Vessi and more to stop/monitor coupon leaks to sites/extensions like Honey, CapitalOne, RetailMeNot, and more to boost your DTC margins

Try it 14 days free - No risk, Cancel anytime

Why “Ugly” Works

Plain-text or minimal-style emails have quietly built a reputation for outperforming their glossy peers in key areas: open rates, click-through rates, deliverability, and even reply volume.

Not because they’re cleverer or trendier. But because they lean into one crucial principle: believability.

When an email looks and feels like something a real person would send, not a brand machine, it earns attention, trust, and action.

Let’s break that down:

1. They feel personal

These emails don’t pretend to be polished campaigns. They read like messages from a colleague or friend. No graphics. No headers. Just a short note that says, “This is for you.”

That personal cue changes how people engage.

2. They dodge the filters

HTML-heavy emails are easier for Gmail and Outlook to label as “Promotions” or “Marketing.”
Plain-style emails, with minimal formatting and a conversational tone, are more likely to slip into the Primary tab.

That small difference can dramatically affect open rates.

3. They work across devices

You don’t have to worry if your design holds up on Apple Mail, Gmail, Outlook, or mobile. Plain-text emails are naturally responsive and universally readable.

For mobile-first audiences, that’s a quiet but serious advantage.

4. They don't announce "I'm selling you something"

When people open a heavily designed email, they know exactly what’s coming. They’re immediately on guard.
A simpler email often flies under the radar, just long enough to spark interest or curiosity.

The Data Doesn’t Lie

Let’s anchor this in real-world numbers:

• 17–40% higher click-through rates: Seen in multiple A/B tests comparing text-style vs. graphic-heavy emails.

• 61% more demo bookings: One SaaS company ditched its polished template in favor of plain-text and saw a huge spike.

• 28% more opens: Emails sent from individuals rather than brands saw significantly better performance.

These aren't edge cases. They're common results across B2B, SaaS, coaching, and info-product spaces.

When to Keep the Design

This isn’t a blanket condemnation of design. There are absolutely times when design adds value:

• You’re showcasing physical products (e.g., e-commerce)

• You’re sending a multi-topic newsletter

• Your brand relies on aesthetics and polish (e.g., luxury, fashion, architecture)

In those cases, visuals help communicate. But if your goal is action, clicks, replies, conversions, the simplest approach often wins.

Especially when the goal is starting a conversation, not just broadcasting an announcement.

How to Make Plain Emails Actually Work

Going plain isn’t just about removing images. It’s about writing like a person, not a brand.

Here’s how to do it well:

• Send from a real person: “Rachel at Acme” is better than “The Acme Team.” Even better? Just “Rachel.”

• Write like a human: Skip the corporate tone. Use contractions. Say “you.” Ask questions. Be direct.

• Focus on one clear message: One CTA. One point. One job for the email to do.

• Keep formatting simple: Single column. No bold for every other line. Clean breaks between thoughts.

• Include a P.S.: It’s often the second most-read part of the email, and a great place for a soft CTA or extra nudge.

A Strategic Advantage (Hiding in Plain Sight)

Most brands still over-rely on polish. And that creates a powerful contrast opportunity.

When your message looks like every other promo in the inbox, it’s easy to ignore.

But when it looks like a personal note, from one person to another, it has a better shot at being read and acted on.

That’s where the magic lives. Not in how your email looks, but in how it feels.

Want to Try It?

Here’s an idea:

Send your next email in two versions. One, your usual design. The other, a clean, plain-text version with a clear message and one CTA.

Split your list. Compare results. The numbers will tell you everything you need to know.

Until next time,

The InBoXer Team